Zimbabwean Media Lagging Behind In Arts Appreciation

By Raisedon Baya


The standard of arts reporting and critiquing in Zimbabwe is, to say the least, very poor. With the way things are one can safely conclude that the media’s association with the arts has failed to lift the status of arts in the eyes of the public. Instead certain circles of media have perpetuated certain negative attitudes inherited during the colonial era. During the first twenty years after independence local artistes did not make headline news, unless dead or involved in a serious accident or scandal. Local arts stories were reduced to mere paragraphs hidden inside pages of different publications. On television we only got to know of local artists through the low budget local productions where artists like Safirio Madzikatire with his Mukadota Family and Felix Moyo with Kukhula Kokhuphela became household names.


While local arts had no space in local newspapers and even on television international artists from Hollywood and Europe were making huge headlines and commanding full page stories. This created in our people an attitude that local art is substandard and not good for consumption. This is why even today our people still find it hard to buy local art products preferring international ones. Today local youths can tell you the complete biography of some funny American singer with some gangster name or give you the current top 20 hits in America and yet the same youths cannot even come up with two or three names of local singles on the local top 20 charts.


The negative attitude towards things local is slowly changing, especially in the public media. Many thanks to the 75% local talent policy which arm twisted public media houses to turn to local artists first. The 75% policy was not a total success for two reasons. The percentage was too high for a sector that hardly had anything ‘broadcastable’ on the shelves. Secondly, there was no investment by both government and the private sector in the arts to meet this 75% content demanded by the policy and in the end programming became an unbearable bore. However, the idea behind the policy was excellent. It is what the arts needed   - policies that push for proper respect of the arts and investments in the sector.


While silently applauding the 75% policy we cannot ignore the fact that it did nothing to change the editorial policy of the independent and private media, especially with regard to arts and culture. The same dismissive attitude towards local artists remains entrenched in a lot of media houses. For how else can one explain a publication that splashes Beyonce Knowles’ half naked body over half a page with no accompanying story and then goes for four to six months without a local arts story? What can we say about media houses that get invited to local arts events, promise a story and deliver nothing?  It is not mere promotional stories that the arts seek for from the media. There is a possibility of great collaborations, great business opportunities and developmental work that could result from the arts associating with the media and vice versa. However, these possibilities have never been explored in Zimbabwe.


The second problem is lack of journalists knowledgeable in arts matters. The concern among the arts sector in Zimbabwe is that most arts journalists do not seem to understand the very sector they are supposed to be writing about. And those that would have gained some basic understanding have been moved to either the hard news or business desks. The arts sector is where most aspiring journalists cut their teeth, so to speak. There are no rules, no standards to maintain, no role models to emulate. This is the sector where anything and everything goes. Arts journalists’ efforts, as reflected by their stories, show serious weaknesses. There is lack of research, lack of arts appreciation, and a total absence of the art of critiquing in the stories. The arts sector needs journalists and art critics that can enrich it with insightful thinking, progressive views, and critical perspectives. It needs journalists with enough clout to change the way our people see the arts – journalists who are not going to take every bit of information they receive at face value. These journalists and critics must also be able to demand better works from artists, something that is not happening at the moment.

Raisedon Baya is an award winning playwright and arts critic based in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe.
 

Media Lagging Behind In Arts Appreciation

Posted by Andrew Mulenga at 2010-05-11 18:34
The Zimbabwe situation as pointed out by Raisedon Baya almost mirrors that of Zambia. In a nation of about 12 million citizens. There are only two arts journalists who cover the visual arts. I don't even see things improving anytime soon.

When journalists are invited to exhibitions we focus on the wine, cheese and ministers speech forgetting to review the exhibitions on display, its pathetic!!

Andrew Mulenga
The Post Newspaper,
Lusaka, Zambia.

ditch wine cheese ministers gatherings! get with the art!

Posted by suzy bell at 2010-05-13 20:29
Hi Andrew

why on earth would you bother attending a cheese and wine minister gathering style exhibition ;) Check out what is happening on the underground arts scene, isn't that more engaging?

Please mail me the type of arts stories you do, I would like to read them and learn more about the arts scene in Zambia.

Do you have an arts blog perhaps?

Suzy Bell
www.suzybell.co.za

same problem here

Posted by David Tumusiime at 2010-05-13 17:33
I guess Uganda and Zimbabwe are more alike than I thought. Same issues here except we do not even have the cushion of an enforced 75% local content in all media. It is a sea of sharks here and only musicians get any real attention, if you can even call it that.

The question is what can we do to make a difference?

what can we do as arts writers to make a difference?

Posted by suzy bell at 2010-05-13 20:24
Hi David

Great to see your interest and passion on this subject.
There are many ways we can make a difference. But as we discovered in our meetings in Harare as we worked through ways to create opportunities in the arts media to form an African Arts Journalists' network we were thrilled at how many opportunties there were. But we were aware of limitations particular to each country like in post-conflict countries like Sierra Leone that electricity can go off for up to 18hours a day making internet use very difficult and printing etc Freedom of press was a big issue in some countries, lack of critical analysis and arts journalism training was another problem but at the end of it we felt positive sharing ideas on training and mentoring, planning to become a professional organised network and much more which once we have finalised all our documents and ideas with our task team we can share with other arts journalists.

In the meantime keep writing great, local, original arts stories and share arts contacts with others as I can with you for more fresh stories on the net. Share your arts stories with other writers too. Create your own blog on African arts and send us your links. Suggest to your editor cross-linking your stories on the web with short video links to Youtube by creating a vlog. If you don't have access to a video camera team up with a young film studies student keen to get experience and credit their video clip at the end of your story and link it to your blog/vlog to get more people online to more of your other arts stories. That is what i do in Cape Town and it is working for me and gets more artists on the net. Equally utilise radio if you can to get more arts coverage.
And do let us know specifically what are the major obstacles you are facing and as a team we can all discuss the issues and share ideas to start making a difference.

Suzy Bell
Cape Times arts columnist, curator, writer and poet
www.suzybell.co.za

African Arts Journalist's Network

Posted by suzy bell at 2010-05-13 20:02
I was very fortunate to recently be a guest of the progressive Arterial Network and the African Arts Institute with about twenty inspiring arts writers from across Africa from Cameroon, Ghana, Burkina Faso, Uganda, Zambia, Botswana, Tanzania, Mauritius, Mozambique, Malawi, Sierra Leone, Senegal to Kenya. We met late April in Harare to stimulate discussions about the state of arts journalism in Africa and discuss creating an African Arts Journalists’ Network to mentor and train young arts writers, to generate interest and discussion about contemporary and traditional art forms on the continent and in the Diaspora, and much more currently in the process of coming to life. We met key cultural players in Harare, and attended the exhilarating six-day Harare International Festival of the Arts. I wish I had met you Raisedon as you sound wonderfully dynamic and just the type of arts critic we need on board. Please send me a link to your website so I may learn more about your plays.
We set up a task team and once we have finalised the network we will invite you and all those interested when we launch to join our group in the long term interests of arts journalism excellence in Africa. There is hope for arts journalism and working together we can make positive changes. But let's keep up this discussion across Africa and raise the issues further and share the opportunities for positive change.

Suzy Bell
www.suzybell.co.za
Cape Times Arts Columnist, curator, writer and poet

what we can do to improve the arts situation reporting

Posted by David Tumusiime at 2010-05-17 12:20
Hi Suzy,

Funny you should talk about the urgent need to make the contacts all over the continent of the journalists who write about the arts, I was actually thinking the very same thing after reading that article, though I wondered how feasible and helpful it would be.

I personally wrote a blog for close to four years www.madandcrazy.blogspot.com that concerned itself with the arts before I decided to take a year out in 2009. Of course I'm an arts journalist in Kampala, Uganda and fully know the challenges of trying to interest editors in running stories about the arts. It is all politics, politics, and sports lately, with there even being fan clubs for premier league sports teams, amazingly!

But I do think there is something in trying to make those individual links to begin with with other arts journalists all over the continent and I'm certain something wonderful will come from the exchange of ideas.

I know I have certainly been so stimulated by Raisedon Baya's article that I'm in the process of crafting a reply/take on the issue from my point of view!

Arts journalism tools

Posted by Joseph Ngunjiri at 2010-05-20 14:19
I am all for arts journalism training. For the sake of the arts, arts journalists need to have some bargaining power within media houses. As it is arts journalists are regarded as surplus requirements in newsrooms, and their pages are regarded as mere fillers, that are the first on the chopping board when an urgent and unexpected advert crops up.
Most arts journalists work on freelance basis, and rarely will they be fully employed as opposed to their colleagues who cover
'important' beats like say politics and business.
If properly harnessed, the arts industry in Africa can be an important source employment and foreign exchange for a country. Just look at Hollywood in the US, Bollywood in India, and lately Nollywood in Nigeria. These three movie industries rake in serious cash for the countries involved.
I am particularly impressed by Nigeria's Nollywood, which has provided a lucrative alternative for Nigerian artistes who otherwise find themselves locked out the corruption-ridden oil industry in that country.
But for the art industry to really pick up in Africa, there needs to be serious linkages with the media, hence the media needs to take the arts seriously just as they do politics.
If mainstream media houses cannot find it within themselves to accomodate the arts, then we need alternative and specialist media outlets that deal primarily with the arts, and believe you me the consumers are there.
I will give the case of Citizen TV in Kenya. Before it came into the scene, existing TV stations used to treat viewers to stale syndicated - and cheaply acquired - shows from the US and Mexico. No station would touch touch local artistes. The argument here was that only foreign artistes sell.
When Citizen TV came into the scene, and through a dynamic manager, they started investing in local TV drams shows, whose ratings today are shoting through the roof. Additionally, they started a local musical show called Tafrija (Extravaganza in Kiswahili) which features music mostly from the village and viewers love that show. The demand was such that the station had to add more time to the duration of that show.
The result is such that advertisers queue to have their adverts aired on Citizen TV as that is where the viewership is. Citizen's example rubbishes the notion that local content does not sell. I could go on and on about the positives of investing in local arts.
The bottomline however is that we need journalists who appreciate the arts and not those who have an eye on other 'lucrative' fields.
The bottomline here is that above all else, an arts journalits also needs to be an artiste. That is the only way they can appreciate and positively critique the art industry.
And this is where journalism training comes in.
Joseph Ngunjiri
www.kenyanbooks.wordpress.com
Sunday Nation arts correspondent

Arts in Africa Blog
« September 2010 »
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30
Arts in Africa Blog:
More...
Log in


Forgot your password?
New user?